Indian · Bite / Side / Appetizer
Machh'er Chop
Kolkata's fish croquette: a fiery, sweet-sour mash of fish and onion, crumbed and deep-fried.
314kcal per serving, as written
The biggest sources are oil for deep-frying (31%) and breadcrumbs (17%). Set your target below and we'll rescale it.
- Kolkata, Bengal, East India
- 1 h 30 min
- Non-Vegetarian
- hot
Adapted from a recipe by Bong Eats, Bong Eats (bongeats.com)
Source and data
Adapted from “Machh'er Chop” by Bong Eats (Bong Eats (bongeats.com)), accessed 2026-11-21. We use this published recipe as a reference for the dish's ingredients, proportions and technique. The method on this page is written by A Light Hand, and the original author hasn't reviewed or endorsed this adaptation. Nutrition figures are estimates, and the calorie-adjusted versions haven't been kitchen-tested. Published servings: 12 chops.
Something off with this recipe? Tell us
How we sourced and calculated this
Region: Kolkata, Bengal, East India (as described by the recipe source).
How we read this recipe
- The source says Bengali homes make it from rui or katla and Kolkata cabins from bhetki trimmings; it uses aar (a large catfish). We count rohu (IFCT 2017).
- Each of the 12 chops is one serving. The source lists 257 kcal per chop; our figure (about 310) is higher, mostly from the breading and absorbed oil we estimate.
- The breading (flour, egg, crumbs) has no amounts in the source; we count 2 eggs, ½ cup flour and 1½ cups crumbs for 12 chops (estimate). All the coating is counted, though some is always left on the plate, so the real figure is a little lower.
- Aamchur, MSG-free bhaja moshla and gorom moshla have no separate composition data; the two masalas are counted as garam masala and the aamchur isn't counted.
- The oil for deep-frying isn't eaten in full. We count what the food absorbs, estimated at 10% of the wet batter weight (anchored to USDA's home-prepared falafel); it's marked as an estimate on the ingredient.
Estimated weights
- Green chilies, slit: 2.5 × 5 g per green chili (small Indian green chili) (estimate).
- Garam masala: Bhaja moshla (roasted cumin, coriander and chilli) is counted as garam masala.
- Flour (maida), for dredging: No amount in the source; ½ cup for 12 chops (estimate).
- Eggs, beaten (for coating): No amount in the source; 2 eggs for 12 chops (estimate).
- Breadcrumbs: No amount in the source; 1½ cups for 12 chops (estimate).
- Oil for deep-frying (amount absorbed): Oil absorbed while deep-frying, estimated at 10% of the wet batter weight (about 1327 g here, soaked dal counted at twice its dry weight). USDA's home-prepared falafel (FDC 172455), a deep-fried soaked-legume batter like a vada, is 17.8 g fat per 100 g against about 4 g in the raw mix, and loses about a third of its weight as water in the fryer: roughly 10 g of oil absorbed per 100 g of wet batter. Real uptake varies with oil temperature and batter moisture.
Data notes
- Rohu IFCT 2017, code S006. From the Indian Food Composition Tables 2017 (National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad), read from the ifct2017 data package's transcription. IFCT reports energy in kJ; converted at 4.184 kJ per kcal. Check against the printed tables before commercial use.
- Spices, cumin seed USDA FDC 170923, SR Legacy. Also used for ground cumin. USDA's teaspoon weight is for whole seed.
- Spices, coriander seed USDA FDC 170922, SR Legacy. Used for coriander powder.
- Spices, pepper, red or cayenne USDA FDC 170932, SR Legacy. Proxy for Kashmiri red chili powder, which has no USDA entry. Both are ground dried Capsicum; heat differs, energy is assumed similar.
- GARAM MASALA (Sands Impex) USDA FDC 2525305, Branded. Spice blends vary by brand; SR Legacy has no garam masala entry.
- Oil, canola USDA FDC 172336, SR Legacy. Used for recipes that call for unspecified neutral cooking oil.
Nutrition reference: USDA FoodData Central (https://fdc.nal.usda.gov) and the Indian Food Composition Tables 2017 (National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad), retrieved 2026-11-21. Cooking losses (oil left in the pan, marinade left in the bowl) are not subtracted, so these estimates lean high. Full method and every food record.